Let’s go. Well, thank you so much for taking the time to join me and anybody else who’s joining us live. My name is Christa Fairbrother. I’m an aqua yoga coach and trainer, and I live here in Florida. And I’m joined today by Dr. Steffany Moonaz, who is out in California, who is the founder of Yoga for Arthritis. And Dr. Moonaz, would you take a second to introduce yourself to anybody who’s joining us live today? Yeah.

I’m a yoga therapist and a yoga scientist. So I study the effects of yoga practices for people who are living with arthritis in all kinds of different forms. I have a doctorate in public health that prepares me to do that. And I, clinically, as a yoga therapist, work exclusively with people who have arthritis and chronic pain conditions.

Land Yoga for Osteoporosis

Excellent. And I invited Steffany here to join me today, partly because I’m passionate about helping people who live with arthritis find more comfort through the tools of yoga, especially in the pool, because I am a person who lives with arthritis. And as a person who lives with arthritis, I don’t see osteoporosis talked about in the larger arthritis community very often. And we’ve got osteopenia, which progresses to osteoporosis. And I thought Steffany and I could talk about this and raise a little bit awareness about this, as well as provide some tools to potentially manage your osteopenia or osteoporosis in a way that is also arthritis friendly if you’re living with that as well. So Steffany, can you please share a little bit about the research and what yoga can do for osteoporosis on land? Yeah, absolutely.

I think especially during Arthritis Awareness Month, this is important to talk about because it is a common comorbidity. People who have arthritis can also have osteoporosis, especially if you have osteoarthritis, the names are similar enough that it’s easy to get them confused, and they are completely different disease processes. So arthritis is a degeneration of the joint tissue, the connective tissue in the joint. And that can be due to degenerative changes, due to stress on the joints, due to aging. But it could also be a systemic process, an autoimmune condition that results in the breakdown of joint tissue.

Similarly, but different, osteoporosis is the breakdown of bone tissue. So there’s connective tissue, the cartilage that’s in the joint, and then there’s the bone tissue that actually makes up the joint. And so you can simultaneously be losing cartilage and also be losing bone. We tend to lose bone as we get older. Some people say that osteoporosis is actually a pediatric disease because the less bone you build as a child, the less of it you have to lose as an adult. And things that contribute to bone loss are things like a sedentary lifestyle. And if you are in pain because you have arthritis and it’s hard to move, you could be at greater risk for losing bone.

Also, if you didn’t have a lot of bone-building in your younger years, then also you might be set up for bone loss later in life. And I’m wearing this shirt that is about arthritis awareness related to kids. Kids get arthritis, too. And if you’re a kid with arthritis and you’re not able to be as active as much of the time, that could also set you up for osteoporosis later in life. So there is this intersection. There’s a question between those that is really important to consider.

As we age, we could end up living with both of these simultaneously. The way that you counter osteoporosis is by stressing the bones. The more stress we put on a bone, the more it grows. Bones grows in response to stress. The challenge is the weaker your bones are, the more dangerous it can be to stress your bones too much. So we can put a lot of stress on our bones when they’re young and healthy and build up bone density. But once we start to lose bone, we have to be careful about that stress. We want enough stress that our bones stay strong but not so much stress that our bones fracture.

And so the greatest risk with osteoporosis is that you end up with fracture. Do you want to chime in at all, Christa, before I keep going?

Just that when you say stress on the bone, you mean the eustress, the good stress. And that is muscular effort. And that’s what we’re going to talk about today.  We are, of course, not talking about the damage which you spoke to, but that idea of how do we challenge our bones and then build muscle, which therefore encourages our bones to say, Wow. I got to respond to this, and I got to lay down some layers and protect this body and have the structure to support this body that’s working hard in a good way.

Yeah, excellent. So there are two main ways that we stress the bone in a good way. One is gravity. Gravity presses down on our body. That is a form of force. And so gravity, and I’m really interested to hear how Christa talks about this in the water because you have more buoyancy and therefore less effect of gravity on the bone. Another is by muscles pulling on the bone. So when we build muscles, which also is by stressing them, the greater the amount of stress, the good amount of stress on a muscle, helps a muscle to grow. The muscle pulls on the bone, helps the bone to grow. Okay, so I hope that Christa is going to demonstrate a pose on… Do you to start with water poses, and then I go to land or the other way around, Christa? Or you want me to just talk about the research first?

Well, why don’t you talk about the research and then go to land? Because I think a lot of people are more comfortable with that land approach and are a little more aware of it. And I’ll offer mine as a contrast to what people might know better. Perfect.

Okay. So some really fascinating things out of the research related to osteoporosis and bone loss and how yoga can be practiced. And I’m really focusing on Asana. Of course, there are lots of other practices in yoga’s toolbox, and a lot of them can be really important, especially for managing pain conditions like arthritis. When we’re talking about the physiology of the bone, I’m really going to focus on Asana, and I think Christa is going to do the same.

Okay, so something fascinating about the literature is that There actually is not very good evidence that yoga can grow back bone for people who are experiencing bone loss. Osteopenia is the milder stage of bone loss and osteoporosis is more severe. However, what the research does show is that yoga can help to sustain bone density. And that actually is a win because when we’re in osteopenia or osteoporosis, we are steadily losing bone over time. So if yoga practices can help us to maintain the bone that we have, that’s a win. Now, to actually grow bone with physical activity, you probably need more resistance kinds of activity. And so yoga can be part of a toolbox of activity that helps us to maintain bone.

Interestingly, also, it’s really important to know, where is my bone loss? Because our bones don’t degenerate at the same rate throughout in the whole body. So if you’re having DEXA scan, the body scan that measures the bone density of your skeleton, they might identify places where your bone is weaker. And oftentimes, it’s in the spine or it’s in the femoral neck of the hip. And so that’s important to know is, where is my bone at risk? Where do I want to be careful and also be stronger? And so there is no evidence that increasing the range of motion of the hip puts risk on the femoral neck for people with osteopenia or osteoporosis. In other words, you don’t have to worry about bending your hips deeply, even if you have osteoporosis or osteopenia in your hips. Check this with your doctor because it depends on severity and everybody is different. But when you have osteoporosis in the spine, there actually is some risk with severe flexion. And this is not flexion of the spine. Here, I’m flexing the hips. It’s about the joint flexing the spine is rounding. So if we did a severe rounding.

Imagine that I rounded my spine and then somebody sat on my back, which has happened in a yoga class. That’s a lot of stress on a spine when it has experienced bone loss. So we’re going to be actually very careful about going too deep with too much force in a rounded spine, but we don’t have to worry about that with the hips. A great way to build bone density by building muscle strength is a pose called Chair Pose. Christa is going to show you how to do this in the water. I love this when we’re talking about in Arthritis Awareness Month because Chair Pose can actually be challenging for people who have arthritis. I’m going to show you why.

Okay, well, in order to show you why, I have to take my camera a little bit. Forgive me. All right. I’m going to do my best here by backing way up. All right, so we go into Chair pose by imagining that we’re sitting in a Chair. So if I turn sideways, I’m going to sit back like there’s a Chair behind me to sit on. When I do that, I am using the muscles that help my legs to strong, which helps the bones of my legs to stay strong, which is where we’re talking about people can have osteopenia or osteoporosis.

The trouble is when I do that, you can’t really see my knees very well. But if you try this, you will see your knees, where do they go? If your hips are going back, something has to counter that. And so your knees are going to go forward. Hips go back, knees go forward as I go into a traditional Chair pose, the trouble with that is if you have arthritis in your knees, you actually don’t want your knees to be going forward. Lots of you in yoga classes might know that when we go into a lunge, we want to be really careful that our knee doesn’t go past our ankle because it puts a lot of stress on the knee joint. So going into a Chair can be good for building bone strength, but it can be bad for arthritis in the knees. How can we address that? One way is the wall. So if I come up to the wall and I put my back against the wall and I walk my feet forward, well, now, if I bend into Chair pose, my hips can’t go back because they can’t go through this wall.

The reason that I’m able to keep my knees from going past my ankles is because the wall is holding me up. The wall is preventing me from falling back. If I tried to do this without the wall and keep my knees in line with my ankles, I would fall backwards. We’re using this prop of the wall in order to protect the knees while also strengthening the leg muscles and the leg bones.

So I can sit against the wall here, and I can have my shoulders against the wall if I want to do it that way, or I can do a more traditional orientation and bend at the hips, you’re keeping a nice long spine. Now, I don’t want you to think that you can’t ever round the spine if you have osteopenia, because we do need some stress on the joints, on the bones, just not too much. So from here, you can take your arms up. If you have shoulder challenges, you can take your arms forward. You can do cactus position with the arms. But the longer you stay here, the more you will notice your leg muscles are really working And so this is a great pose for building leg strength and leg bone density.

I’m going to show you one more thing related to the yoga research, which I found really fascinating. There’s this great study, and maybe we can link to it in the chat thread here. It is a study of people with osteoporosis. So these are postmenopausal women who have osteoporosis. And the intervention was a single asana, a single pose. And that pose is Tree pose.

Now, Tree pose, you might think, okay, well, that’s really focused on balance, not so much focused on bone strength. Why would they do that with people who have osteoporosis? Because if you have osteoporosis, you are at risk of fracture. You know what increases your risk of a fracture? A fall. If you have osteoporosis and you fall, you’re at much greater risk of fracture in bone than if you don’t have osteoporosis and you fall. For people who have bone loss, osteopenia osteoporosis, it’s really important to reduce your risk of falls. In this study, they found that two minutes a day of Tree pose was enough to statistically significantly reduce the risk of falls for postmenopausal women with bone loss. Okay, so what else do you do for two minutes every single day?

You brush your teeth. I have been saying this for years. Stand in Tree pose when you brush your teeth. Okay, so for those of you who may be unfamiliar, I’m going to demonstrate Tree pose, and there are a few variations that you can use for this. Do this every single day while you brush your teeth, and you will reduce your risk of falls, which is going to reduce your risk of fracture.

Meanwhile, do other exercises to increase your bone strength so that you also reduce your risk of fracture. So you stand on two feet, shift your weight over to one side. You can use this wall or a Chair to hold on to. You rotate your hip out to the side. Remember, that’s not a risky move. Rotate your hip out. You can bring your foot anywhere along the leg. You don’t want to put it on the inside of the knee, but you can bring it above if you have the mobility to do that. This might not feel great in the knee for people who have osteoarthritis in the knee. So you might want to bring your foot lower down, but you’re standing on one foot, and then you want to play with taking your hand away from that Chair.

If you’re in the bathroom brushing your teeth, hold on to the counter. As you’re brushing your teeth with one hand, hold on to the counter with the other hand. See if you can pick your hand up. So you got two minutes to brush your teeth. One minute on one leg, switch over to the other side, do another minute on the other leg. Reduce your risk of fall, reduce your risk of fracture. Christa, I’m going to turn it over to you.

Aqua Yoga for Osteoporosis

Excellent. Thank you, Steffany. Those were all really helpful points, and we did have a request to post that study. So sometime later today, we will get that in the comments for Mary Beth, who asked that.

Awesome. Will do. (HERE is the research study Steffany mentioned)

Perfect. I’m going to piggyback on these ideas that Steffany shared, starting with, well, the research. I have to be clear from the get-go. Unfortunately, we have no aqua yoga research. So if I have any researchers listening who want to do some aqua yoga research, get in touch with me. I would love to be able to stop saying this. The research we do have is on aquatic exercise for osteoporosis and osteopenia. And what that research has found is people who participate in aquatic exercise do actually show improvements in their osteopenia/osteoporosis, and can build up some bone, partly because the people who come to aquatic exercise can’t exercise on land.

So it’s this idea of as we spoke to, muscular effort builds bone. And if you’re not able to create muscular effort on land, the reduced impact you’re going to have in water is still okay because you are at least getting some exercise at all. And why we have that reduced effort in the water is when I’m at my mid-chest height, I’ve offloaded 70 % of my weight. And we also, another huge benefit in the water, as Steffany spoke to, we do not have the fall risk.

I’m not going to fall here. So I can perhaps challenge myself with some of these balance postures, some of these strength postures in a way that I would struggle with on land. So this idea of if I increase the muscular effort for a longer period, I’m going to build some muscle really can be an opportunity in the pool as well. So I’m going to go through these steps of Chair pose and how I can start in Chair pose and then gradually increase the effort so that I’m building that muscle and applying that good stress to my bones.

I’m going to show you from the front first, that idea of Chair pose. Here in the water, we’re not raising our arms because we have this beautiful surface of the water. So having my hands on the surface of the water, my feet are hip-bone distance apart in Chair, I bend my knees and sink and my hips, knees and toes face in the same direction. I’m going to spin on the same side. We started here. I bend the knees, I find my Chair pose. If I were to hold this for two minutes, I am not expending nearly the muscular effort that Steffany did here.

So what can I do to increase my effort? I can use the increased viscosity of the water and move my arms because moving my arms wants to pitch me back and forth. I’ll show you from the side. If I move in both my arms, I have to work to not go anywhere. If I’m going to hold this Chair pose and not go anywhere, I’m exerting quite a lot of muscular effort, both in my thighs and in my core. So this would be the most gentle way to practice Chair pose while applying some muscular effort. If I want to amp it up a little bit, I can do this asymmetrically. If I only move one hand through the water, now that water perturbation is asymmetrical, and I have to apply even more muscular effort to counteract that. If I want to amp it up even further, instead of moving the arms, I can move the legs because now I’m going to be on one leg. And if I were to take this leg in and out, I’m exerting a lot of muscular effort on the leg holding me up. I’m exerting muscular effort on the leg that’s moving in and out.

I’ll show you that one from the side as well. Come into my Chair pose. I’m offering the in and out. Of course, you can do this action in any plane. It does not have to be in and out. I can move forward and back. I can move on the diagonal. But as soon as I have offloaded all the weight on the one leg, that leg is working really hard.

The other thing I can do is because, I have so much reduced impact in the water because of the water’s buoyancy, I might be able to add a little bit of impact with a jump. Or these kinds of things that I wouldn’t necessarily be able to do on land. We have a very robust aquatic exercise study that has shown an aquatic jumping program did improve bone mass in postmenpausal women. So if I’m in my Chair pose, I can maybe jump it a little. I’ll go to the side. Or maybe I could do a full-on what we would call an aqua burpee. So I could really jump it up and then swing into what we would call a level three move, which is both my feet are getting off the pool floor if I were to jump and bring it up

And I offer that with the perspective of, of nowhere in the yoga sutras does it actually say our yoga has to be slow. So if I am continuing to progress to a point of where I’m moving a little faster, if I can do that in a way that still honors my yoga philosophy, still honors my breathwork, keeps me concentrating, and keeps me present in my own body, I happen to think that’s still yoga practice, even though I might be deviating from what we consider the more traditional yoga shapes. So that would be my perspective here on the Chair pose in the water.

We can do Tree pose in the water.  The shape of Tree pose in the water is virtually the same. I would start in my Mountain pose, put a bend in one knee, turn that knee out to the side, attach it at my ankle. So leaving the toes on the pool floor is, of course, always an option because then if I apply that idea of, wow, I’m creating some water perturbation, I’ve really challenged my balance.

I can choose to bring the leg up to the thigh and challenge my balance in that way. Yes, I do have the option of bringing the arms overhead as well as I would on land. So our Tree pose is virtually the same shape in the water. The challenge is, of course, even someone as dedicated as me does not brush my teeth in the pool. So you have to create these extra opportunities to make it to the pool and practice. And it can be a little more challenging to put into your daily life. So the important thing to remember about aqua yoga in the pool and what does it do for osteopenia and osteoporosis while perhaps managing arthritis is that idea of I need to create effort. I need to move my muscles in a way that’s going to challenge my bones because I’ve offloaded so much of my weight. So Steffany, any feedback on that or things that you would like to add based on what I offered?

I can’t see your video. So I’m like, imagining the activities that you’re going through. I can’t wait to watch this recording and see the burpees in the water.

Yeah. So you’ll get something to practice next time you go to the pool. So excellent. So Steffany, to wrap up, Can you please let everybody know how they can get in touch with you if they would like to work with you for more information about what we’ve talked about today?

Yeah, absolutely. Thank you, Christa. The best way to find me is at our website, https://www.arthritis.yoga. We have a couple of offerings, recommendations that are related to the content today, and I think Kylie is going to be sharing a link to that in the chat, so you can access those and learn more.

Excellent. Thank you so much. And if anybody wants to get a hold of me, my website is https://www.christafairbrother.com.  And again, I can help you more with the information we shared today. And I am working on doing a teaching aqua yoga for arthritis certification on top of the basic certifications that I offer because I am so passionate about this, as Steffany knows, since we’ve been colleagues for a long time now. So thank you so much.

I love how you’re taking all of this great information and translating it into the water with your skillset. And I do hope somebody will pick up that baton and do some research on this because we have evidence about the effects of yoga on land and the effects of exercises in the water. But we’re missing that intersection.

Yes. So someday in our lifetime, we can make that work. So, yes. Any researchers talk to us. We’d love to help you with this. So we really appreciate you all taking the time to join us live today. If you had a question that we did not address live, please leave it in the comment and we’ll circle back around. And we look forward to continuing to connect with you.

Everybody have a beautiful Arthritis Awareness month. Spread the word so people understand more about what it’s like to live with these conditions and how we can all thrive.

That’s right. Thank you so much. Take care.

If you liked the Osteoporosis Aqua Yoga Tips, see these other videos:

Which Core Exercise is Best at the Pool

Strength & Stretch Exercises

Aqua vs. Land Yoga for Arthritis

Vertical graphic that shows Christa Fairbrother in the pool on the top of the graphic.  It's a headshot with her wearing glasses and sunglasses on the top of her head.  Below is Dr. Steffany Moonaz demoing Chair pose on the wall.  The top of the graphic says in blue letters, "Osteoporosis Aqua vs. Land Yoga."

Tags

aqua yoga, osteoporosis


You may also like

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
>